The White House has completed its formal review of the war in The During
Afghanistan and of the U.S. strategy there. Though the review expresses
deep skepticism about the progress of the war, it affirms President
Obama’s plan to begin reducing troops levels in July 2011 and to bring
the majority of U.S. troops home by 2014. Analyzing the state of play in
Afghanistan has always been difficult, but this report comes amid an
unusually mixed series of reports from the country, which alternatively
show promising steps forward as well as discouraging signs of
disintegration. Here’s what reporters, analysts, and pundits are seeing
in today’s war.
summary said the United States continues to kill leaders of Al Qaeda
and diminish its capacity to launch terrorist attacks from the region.
It cited some signs that the United States and its allies have halted or
reversed inroads by the Taliban in Afghanistan and strengthened the
ability of Afghan forces to secure their country, but acknowledged that
the gains are fragile and could be easily undone unless more progress is
made towards hunting down insurgents operating from havens in
U.S. intelligence reports paint a bleak picture of the security
conditions in Afghanistan and say the war cannot be won unless Pakistan
roots out militants on its side of the border, according to several U.S.
officials who have been briefed on the findings,” reports the Associated Press a few days ago. “It
says the war cannot be won unless Pakistan is willing to obliterate
terrorist safe havens in its lawless tribal areas bordering Afghanistan.”
the numbers of American and German troops in the north have more than
doubled since last year, insecurity has spread, the Taliban are
expanding their reach, and armed groups that purportedly support the
government are terrorizing local people and hampering aid organizations.”
in security in Kandahar, Afghanistan’s former capital and the largest
city in the Taliban-dominated south of Afghanistan. In The L.A. Times, Peter Mansoor and Max Boot say we’re doing better than you might think across the crucial southern districts:
a recent 10-day visit at [Petraeus'] invitation, we found a classic,
and successful, counterinsurgency campaign being conducted in the south.
We drove around Kandahar city and saw markets flourishing. Children who
once threw stones at American vehicles now wave at our soldiers. As we
went north into the Arghandab River Valley–a Taliban stronghold until a
few months ago–we found numerous American and Afghan outposts and
soldiers patrolling on foot between them.
and Pressure Dual Citizens,” and (5) “Go Long.”
The White House has completed its formal review of the war in